Home Page | Calendar | Forums | Login | Turn Images On |
Home > People > Opinion
Opinion Archive | James Knight

Opinion


How Mr Men can help us give effective feedback

Anna Price explains how some of the Mr Men characters from the popular Roger Hargreaves books can provide insight into how we communicate with each other.

We have a growing cultural problem that pervades the world of work but also much of the church.  We really don’t like being challenged by one another!  Our sensitivities to mental health problems and desire to be trauma-informed, with good reason, can mean we lack confidence, both of giving and receiving feedback.  In the work-place employers face the pressure from above and have to reluctantly get on with it but face the possibility of staff sickness on mental health grounds.  Parents and teachers, trying to exert authority over teenagers, are likely to get answered with reference to human rights and calling ChildLine!  And those in pastoral ministry will often avoid conflict at all costs.   Our commitment to churches being places of refuge can mean that arguments or tensions are considered a sign of spiritual failure.   And none of us wants to go back to the days of tough love, stiff upper lips and stoicism.
 
Gene L Green writes in his commentary on 1 Thessalonians, ‘While personal correction has become anathema in the church today, ancient opinion was that correction by others was profitable for a person’s wellbeing.’   The Apostle Paul is clear in 1 Thessalonians (5:12-15) that receiving admonishment from leaders and, as congregation members, warning each other and be prepared to intervene in certain situations, is a sign of health in a church.   But how can we understand, experience and give challenge to one another in a way that is truly loving, respectful and constructive?
 
I have based my analysis on a highly regarded book named ‘Radical Candor’ by management expert and author, Kim Scott, which considers this question.  I have added some insights of my own and some Mr Men characters (just to help those of us who find this all a little abstract!).
 
Mr Worry
One trap we can find ourselves falling into is Ruinous Empathy.  So rich in what we consider to be personal care, grace and empathy, we are allow ourselves to be so drawn into the experience of the other and their perspectives to the point that we lose all external perspective.  Politically we become left-leaning, and theologically we desire grace without truth, the New Testament without the Old, Spirit rather than Word.   As Jon Kuhrt writes, we have appreciation without accountability, forgiveness without boundaries, compassion without justice, support without empowerment, always an empathetic ‘yes’ and never a compassionate ‘no’.  We follow the saying, ‘if you can’t think of anything nice to say, don’t say anything at all’.
 
Mr Worry is so worried about the person and what to say, he never says anything.  This extreme empathetic behaviour can lead to the children of God becoming spoilt and churches becoming rich in wealth but lacking purpose or vision. 
 
Mr Nosey 
Then we find the worst of all our behaviours in Manipulative Insincerity.  We become dangerously filled with apathy.  We find it’s easier neither to care for the person, nor for the truth at stake.  Paul in both letters to the Thessalonians warns those that are idle because of their tendency towards gossip and trouble-making.  He says of us when we fall into this trap, ‘they are not busy; they are busybodies!’ (2 Thess. 3:13).  Our demonstrations of care and our sweet talking is sadly insincere because we don’t truly care and we use delightfully crafted words in order to get our own way.  We become prone to back-stabbing and will likely cause painful strife in a community, without anyone really realising.   
 
Mr Nosey tends to find himself getting overly involved in other people’s business.  His self-orientation means the children of God will be neglected and churches emptied. 
 
Mr Uppity (a favourite book of mine) 
Another tendency is a loveless commitment to truth and correctness that leads to the unpleasant behaviours of Obnoxious Aggression.  When leaning this way, we don’t really care how what we say goes down with the hearer.  We have a steer towards law over grace, Old Testament over New Testament, Word rather than Spirit.  We are impatient with the weak and irritable with the failings of others.  We probably swing to the political right, and are insistent on telling it straight, not beating around the bush, and going at someone, again and again.  We ensure there is accountability but there is no appreciation, we have boundaries without forgiveness, justice with no compassion, and are much more likely to say ‘no’ to things, rather ‘yes’. 
 
Mr Uppity is an unrelenting critical voice, who tends towards leaving the children of God battered and churches suffering from his unrelenting abuse. 
 
Mr Good 
Finally,  we have what we should all long to be like - to speak with Radical Candor (the concept and book of Kim Scott).  The example of Christ is to have mature form of love and care for the community.  Full of grace and truth, his words are lovingly truthful and truthfully loving.  It’s not that he beats us over the head because he ‘loves us’ but he his actions towards us are truly in our best interests.  He speaks from a perspective of weakness not power and perfectly embodies the Old Testament and the New, the Word and Spirit, truth and grace, justice and compassion.  His words are rich in wisdom and discernment, and he nurtures us as the true Shepherd-King, combining gentleness and strength.  He is patient with all and with the types of people found in 1 Thessalonians 5:14-15.  Rather than being cross with the idle, frustrated with the timid or burdened by the weak, He is patient with each and every one of us. He helps and empowers, cares and challenges, encourages and warns, says ‘yes’… and also ‘no’.
 
The ultimate Mr Good is Christ himself and when we move towards His ways, we find the children of God being nurtured into maturity and the church thriving and overflowing with kindness (1 Thess. 5:15).
 
The image above was generated by AI.

 
 
 
Anna Price is Community and Discipleship Lead  at St Mary Magdalene Church in Gorleston, who sees her mission as helping the local church bring transformational change through the holistic care of individuals and by bringing people to together in community.

 

 

The views carried here are those of the author, not of Network Norwich and Norfolk, and are intended to stimulate constructive debate between website users. 

We welcome your thoughts and comments, posted below, upon the ideas expressed here. 

Click here to read our forum and comment posting guidelines

(Author: )

See feedback for this article


Articles in this group

Where do we find true comfort?
Catherine Ayre explains where she finds the source of real comfort in her life, and resolves to spend more time reading the gospels.

Being thankful for the glimmers and sparkle
Ruth Lilley has been recording and giving thanks for the little moments of joy in her life, and finds this provides considerable comfort.

Moving on with God from things of the past
Jane Walters has been unwinding with a nostalgia trip, but reminds us that relishing the future with God is more rewarding.

A new approach to sharing my faith
Catherine Ayre finds that the power of prayer really can help in daily life, and believes that actions can sometimes speak louder than words when reaching out.

Celebrating International Women’s Day in church
Anna Heydon’s church held a special service to mark International Women’s Day earlier this year, and suggests that more churches may benefit from doing something similar next year.

Try delving deeper into the bible
Catherine Ayre remembers buying “pick and mix” sweets from Woolworth, but is wary of applying the same technique to her bible reading.

Taking it slowly – one verse at a time
Jane Walters has adopted a more pedestrian pace for a while when reading her bible, but has found she is gaining new perspectives on what she is reading.

Reach out with Light this Hallowe’en
Anna Price is preparing her Gorleston church for an evening of outreach at the end of this month, and suggests a way forward for other churches to grasp the opportunity to engage with their communities.

The key to loving each other
Ruth Lilley believes we have much to learn from children as we seek to follow Jesus’ command to love and accept each other.

When a prayer seems not enough
Rev Christina Rees gets disturbed by the distressing images she receives, often accompanying charitable appeals, and asks what response is possible for those of us with limited means.

The joy of seeing young people meet with God
Gabi Groenewald-Simmons took the Identity youth group to Newday in July this year, and reports back on what a wonderful and inspiring week it was.

Being a representative for Jesus
Jane Walters reminds us of responsibility Christians have to be reliable representatives for Jesus.

Give humble thanks for God’s harvest provision
Hazel Manley is looking forward to this year’s harvest thanksgiving, and reminds us that it is God’s gracious provision that makes it all possible.

When God has the way ahead planned
Ruth Lilley has been walking the Norfolk Coast Path, and her experience reminds her of the way Gods helps her navigate her way through life.

Finding your soul by swimming in the sea
Christina Rees loves swimming in the sea, and explains why this helps to deepen her relationship with God.

Try showing kindness by lifting a burden
Jane Walters has been discovering new ways of showing the Fruits of the Spirit in our lives, and suggests another interpretation of kindness.

God wants you to love yourself
Ruth Lilley has been reflecting on God’s greatest commandment, and reminds us that it includes having love for ourselves.

Taking a daily break to refresh the soul
Rev Christina Rees has discovered a way to find time to listen to God each day, and have a mini-holiday at the same time!

Tuesday is for World Peace – really?
John Myhill shares his thoughts about the meaning of peace, and how we can strive to be peace-makers.

Is God’s word the foundation of your life?
Jane Walters has been studying Psalm 119, and has realised how much the psalmist’s life revolved around God’s words.

The joy of reading a book you can hold
In this digital age of soundbite news, Rev Patrick Coghlan is urging us to pause and re-discover the satisfaction of reading real books.

Dig deeper to discover the real person inside
Rev Christina Rees reminds us how easy it is to judge people by first impressions, and fail to appreciate the depths of each person God has created.

Cultivating holy curiosity in a diverse church
Rev David Mayne reflects on how ecumenical encounter and theological openness deepen discipleship, enrich ministry, and strengthen Christian unity.

Eyes to see what God has created
Jane Walters has been taking in the beauty of the natural world as she goes walking, and has found that this can sometimes guide her prayers.

When it’s time to look forward, not back
Ruth Lilley explains why looking back may not always be helpful when seeking God’s direction for your life.

Turning hatred for someone into prayer
Rev Christina Rees has been following recent global events, and explains why she prays for the man who appears to be pivotal in so many of them.

We should be caretakers to God’s planet
Hannah Hammond has been putting out her bins, and reminds us that avoiding unnecessary waste helps us to play our part in caring for God’s creation.

The Good Shepherd always knows best!
Stuart Bailey explains how God has used drastic circumstances recently to force him to rest in His loving care.

Welcome - a sanctuary city of orange hearts!
Norwich City of Sanctuary is part of a national movement building a culture of welcome for people seeking safety, and Frances Middleton urges us to welcome these refugees to our city.

Bishop's Easter message of hope and not fear
Easter points to a future shaped by hope not fear says The Bishop of Norwich, the Rt Rev Graham Usher.

When it’s time to respond to God’s call
Jane Walters encourages would-be writers to respond with action rather than excuses, and feels that the same applies whenever God calls for us to act.

Walking in the light of the Saviour
Ruth Lilley offers encouragement to those whose paths seem dark, or who may be unsure which road to take.

Try doing nothing for Lent this year
As Easter approaches, Rev Christina Rees suggests a way of allowing God to break into our busy lives.

Turn to the light in this Gothic age
John Myhill has been reflecting on the darkness of all the Gothic imagery in our lives, and urges us to dwell on all the goodness in our society.

Whose report shall you believe?
Catherine Ayre has been reflecting on the story of Joshua, and reminds us that our words can be a source of great encouragement to others, or simply be destructive.

How should Christians respond to abortion?
Stuart Bailey attended an abortion related prayer meeting back in November, and the evening left him with some nagging thoughts.

Is your thinking and your faith on the level?
Jane Walters has been baking cakes, but they turned out a little lop-sided!

“Let love be your greatest aim”
St Valentine’s day is rapidly approaching, but Ruth Lilley encourages us to show love to others throughout the year.

Celebrating the Light of the world
Next Monday will be the feast of Candlemas, forty days after Christmas. Rev Christina Rees explains the significance of this for Christians.

Hold your nerve, and trust God
Jane Walters was recently faced with deciding whether or not to embark on a cross-country journey with her team in a potential snowstorm, but trusted God for the outcome.

What kind of footprints do I leave?
Ruth Lilley has been walking in the snow, and reflects on the footprints that she leaves behind for others to see.

Now is the time for action!
The New Year is a time when many of us make new resolutions, and Catherine Ayre suggests that now is the time to resolve to take positive action to carry out God’s will.

The lost shepherd who followed the star
From Stalham Baptist Church comes the story of a young shepherd boy who became lost when rescuing a lamb. (Author: Tony Rothe)

When heaven’s peace broke the silence
As Christmas approaches, Hannah Hammond offers advice for finding some peace in this increasingly busy and bustling time of year.

A meaningful countdown to Christmas
Christina Rees is counting down the days to Christmas, but she is reflecting on a more powerful form of Advent calendar.

The power of God’s hope-filled promise
Jane Walters has been working hard to meet commitments and to keep a promise she has made, and reflects on the promises of God that make up the Advent season.

Perhaps we should slow down for Christmas?
Now that the season of Advent has started, Hannah Hammond suggests an antidote to the hustle and bustle of the run-up to Christmas.

Gliding like gulls with God
Ruth Lilley has been watching the gulls flying over the cliffs at Cromer, and wonders whether we have a lesson to learn from them.

Getting your heart ready for Christmas!
As Advent approaches, Rev Christina Rees suggests ways in which we can prepare ourselves for the arrival of the Christmas season.

Be positive – encourage someone today!
Catherine Ayre reminds us how destructive criticism can be, and urges us to encourage someone today instead.


© 2026 Network Norfolk High Accessibility Version. (Full Graphics Version)